Hero of Dunkirk Reply

Why couldn’t the Royal Navy, vastly superior to the German Navy, provide more support for the Dunkirk evacuation?

Picture of British Vice Admiral Sir Bertram Ramsay, who ran the Dunkirk evacuation.
British Vice Admiral Sir Bertram Ramsay (1883-1945) in Dover.

The “Miracle at Dunkirk” was an astonishing operation that was put together on the fly by a previously retired British admiral named Bertram Ramsay, who dragged the Royal Navy brass with him.

As the operation got underway, the Luftwaffe attacked with vigor, since Goering had assured Hitler that his planes could keep the British pinned to the beach. So many British ships were hit that the First Sea Lord (military head of the Navy), Dudley Pound, withdrew the most modern destroyers, leaving Ramsay with the less capable older ships. Ramsay had a phone chat with Pound and must have been very persuasive, because the new ships were restored and went back to work fighting off the Luftwaffe and picking men up from the breakwater at Dunkirk.

What really saved the BEF, of course, was that the RN commandeered dozens of ferry boats, coastal steamers, barges, lighters, work boats, trawlers, and shallow-draft craft of every kind. Along with cabin cruisers and pleasure craft, they picked up men from the beaches as well as the breakwater. About 198,000 British soldiers and 140,000 French and Belgian troops were rescued.

Since the soldiers could not walk on water, the Royal Navy was of course instrumental in the Dunkirk operation. But at first the high command could not imagine rescuing so many. (Neither could the Army high command, actually.) It was largely thanks to Ramsay’s persistence, dogged determination, and willingness to slash or ignore red tape that the “root and core and brain” of the British Army (as Churchill put it) was successfully carried off.

FDR Speaks Reply

How panicked was FDR when he heard about the Pearl Harbor attack?

A picture of FDR speaking to Congress December 8, 1941.

Panic wasn’t FDR’s style. He consulted with his civilian and military advisors, met with the cabinet and leading politicians, talked on the phone with Winston Churchill, and prepared the speech he would give to Congress the next day. Secretary of State Cordell Hull gave him a lengthy, lawyerly draft of a speech; FDR thanked him and put it aside. FDR’s speech was a masterpiece of direct and forceful oratory that rallied the nation and added “day of infamy” to the catalogue of unforgettable phrases.

When he got to the Capitol, Roosevelt had to make his way down the center aisle of the House chamber and up to the rostrum. Of course, he couldn’t walk, but with the help of heavy steel braces and his son’s supportive arm, he could shift his weight from one leg to the other, swivel his hips, and thus move forward. A man who dealt bravely with that sort of handicap was not a man to panic.